Through the Looking Glass

“When I use a word,” Humpty Dumpty says, in rather a scornful tone, “it means just what I choose it to mean – neither more nor less.” “The question is,” says Alice, “whether you can make words mean so many different things.” “The question is,” says Humpty Dumpty, “which is to be master – that’s all.”
— Lewis Carroll, Through the Looking-Glass

Words have power, and who gets to decide what they mean (“which is to be master”) matters. We see it every day: in a world marked by intense division, words are used to inflame, their meanings are disputed, and sometimes they’re quietly rewritten altogether.
Humpty Dumpty believed the speaker is the master of meaning. Leaders sometimes fall into the same trap. We know what we meant, so we assume that’s what people heard. But in leadership, Humpty Dumpty had it backward. The listener decides what our words mean. A comment we intended as a casual observation can land as criticism. A quick “we’ll see” can sound like “no.” A late-night email we wrote in a hurry can keep someone awake wondering what they did wrong.
A leader’s words are amplified. The higher our position, the louder our words become. A passing remark from a colleague is easily forgotten. The same remark from a supervisor gets repeated, analyzed, and remembered. That’s not a reason to stop speaking. It’s a reason to speak with intention.
Clear is kind. In the words of Brené Brown, “Clear is kind. Unclear is unkind.” Brown isn’t giving us permission to “say it like we see it” without regard for its impact. She’s reminding us that vagueness, hinting, and avoiding hard truths often feel kind in the moment but leave people confused and anxious. Thoughtful, clear word choice encourages reflection and growth and builds relational capacity, because people know where they stand.
Words shape who people become. The labels leaders use have a way of coming true. Research on the “Pygmalion effect” has shown that when leaders expect more from people, people often rise to meet those expectations. When we describe someone as “difficult,” “resistant,” or “not leadership material,” we don’t just describe them. We begin to shape how we treat them, and how they see themselves. Choosing words that describe behavior rather than defining identity leaves room for people to grow.
Words must match actions. Our words only mean what our actions prove they mean. If we say “my door is always open” but seem irritated by interruptions, people learn to believe the behavior, not the words. Every gap between what we say and what we do teaches people to discount what we say next.
Words matter by their absence. When leaders stay silent, avoiding a difficult situation or failing to communicate consistently over time, the silence doesn’t stay empty for long. People fill it with assumptions, doubt, mistrust, and fear. Sometimes the most important thing a leader can say is simply, “Here’s what I know, here’s what I don’t know yet, and here’s when I’ll update you.”
So which is to be master? For leaders, the answer is humbling: we don’t control how our words are received, but we are responsible for how they’re chosen. This week, try one small practice. Before an important conversation, email, or announcement, pause and ask: How will this land for the person hearing it? Is it clear? Does it match what I do? And is there something I’ve left unsaid that needs to be spoken?
“We have to remember that our words can either inspire greatness, or they can extinguish the potential of those we lead.”
— Tanveer Naseer

-Full-Color.png)



Comments